If you had to fit the important parts of your life aboard one ship, what would you take?
Clothes, certainly. Bedding. Tools. Something to cook in. Perhaps your Bible or another treasured book. And if you were expecting a baby? You might need a cradle.
The passengers aboard the Mayflower were not packing for a vacation. They were carrying objects needed to establish households in a place where replacements could be difficult—or impossible—to obtain.
That makes the surviving possessions associated with the Mayflower passengers especially fascinating. A cooking pot isn’t merely a pot when the nearest English manufacturer is an ocean away. A musket isn’t merely a weapon when it also helps provide food. A cradle becomes particularly poignant when we remember that babies were born during the voyage and shortly after the ship reached Cape Cod.
Pilgrim Hall Museum preserves several objects traditionally associated with Mayflower passengers, along with early records showing what settlers were advised to bring. Together, they allow us to tell the story of Plymouth in an unusual way: Through the stuff people carried with them.
The Cradle: Because Life Didn’t Wait for Plymouth
Among Pilgrim Hall Museum’s most evocative objects is a cradle traditionally associated with the family of William and Susanna White. Susanna White was pregnant during the Mayflower voyage. Her son Peregrine was born in late November 1620 while the ship was anchored in Cape Cod Harbor. The General Society of Mayflower Descendants identifies him as the first English child born to the Pilgrims in New England.
Imagine packing for that journey while pregnant. You weren’t only thinking about surviving an Atlantic crossing. You were preparing for a newborn. The cradle reminds us that Plymouth was never simply an expedition of explorers. Families crossed the Atlantic together. Women were pregnant. Babies needed care. Children needed feeding and clothing. History continued happening while ordinary family life continued too.
The Cooking Pot: Dinner Depends Upon It
Pilgrim Hall also preserves an iron cooking pot traditionally associated with Myles Standish. It was made in seventeenth-century England and originally stood on long feet so it could be placed directly over a fire. Today, losing a cooking pot is annoying. In early Plymouth, it could become a serious household problem.
Iron goods were among the manufactured products the settlers depended upon Europe to supply. Pilgrim Hall notes that iron tools needed for building houses, cultivating fields and preparing food had to be imported. That helps explain why later provisions lists for New England emigrants included iron pots, kettles, skillets and frying pans. You couldn’t assume Plymouth would have another one waiting.
The pot therefore represents something easy to overlook: Infrastructure could fit inside a suitcase—or, more accurately, a sea chest.
The Musket: One Object, Several Jobs
Then there were firearms. Edward Winslow’s advice to people considering emigration included a musket, along with powder and shot. Early provisions lists likewise emphasize weapons and ammunition. A musket served more than one purpose. It was part of the settlement’s defensive equipment. It was also a hunting tool.
Bradford recorded the availability of waterfowl, wild turkey and venison around Plymouth. Edward Winslow’s famous description of the 1621 harvest celebration begins with Governor Bradford sending four men out “fowling. A musket therefore connected directly with food as well as security. And unlike a modern appliance, it required an entire supporting system. Powder. Shot. Maintenance. Skill. Lose the ammunition and the musket becomes considerably less useful.
The Sword: The Man Behind the Myth
Pilgrim Hall’s collection also includes a sword traditionally associated with Myles Standish. Standish served as Plymouth’s military leader. He had been hired by the Pilgrims for his military experience and was elected captain shortly after the colonists arrived. His sword makes the famous name suddenly physical. Someone wore it. Someone maintained it. Someone carried it through a world in which Plymouth was a tiny settlement surrounded by enormous uncertainty.
Objects can do something biographies sometimes cannot. They collapse four centuries. A man who feels like a character from a history book becomes a person who once wrapped his hand around the handle of an actual sword.
The Bible: Something Worth the Cargo Space
Pilgrim Hall Museum preserves a Bible traditionally associated with William Bradford. For the Pilgrims, books—and Scripture in particular—were not trivial possessions. Pilgrim Hall’s examination of Plymouth libraries shows the importance of religious books in early colonial households. William Brewster’s estate, for example, contained a substantial library. Bradford’s Bible helps us understand something about the choices involved in packing: Every object aboard ship occupied space.
Books are heavy. A person crossing the Atlantic with limited cargo capacity had to decide what deserved to come. For a community whose religious convictions had already driven it from England to Holland and then toward America, Scripture was not simply recreational reading. The physical Bible represents the ideas the Pilgrims believed important enough to carry across an ocean.
The Furniture: Yes, Some Came Too
It is tempting to imagine Mayflower passengers arriving with only tiny bundles of personal possessions. The surviving material record is more complicated. Pilgrim Hall preserves pieces of furniture traditionally associated with Mayflower families, including a great chair associated with William Brewster and other household objects believed to have crossed the Atlantic.
Furniture was valuable. Wood certainly existed in New England, but producing a finished piece required tools, skill and time. Bringing a useful household object could therefore make sense despite the precious cargo space it consumed. A chair wasn’t disposable. A chest wasn’t disposable. A table wasn’t disposable. These were assets.
The Tools: Plymouth Came Packed in Pieces
Perhaps the least glamorous objects were among the most important. Axes. Saws. Augers. Hammers. Shovels. Hoes. Nails. Later provisions lists for settlers heading to New England specified these kinds of tools in remarkable detail.
Why? Because a forest is not a house. A field is not a farm. A tree becomes useful lumber only after somebody has the tools and knowledge necessary to work it. The settlers needed equipment to transform the resources around them into shelter, food and a functioning town.
This is one of the most useful ways to understand what crossed the Atlantic. The colonists couldn’t bring Plymouth with them. But they could bring the tools needed to build Plymouth.
The Window—Packed Flat
One item on Edward Winslow’s provisions list sounds almost absurd to modern ears. He advised prospective settlers to bring paper and linseed oil for windows. Glass was expensive and difficult to obtain. Oiled paper offered a practical substitute that admitted some light while helping close an opening against the weather.
Think about that packing decision. You weren’t merely bringing things to put inside the house. You were bringing part of the house itself. The same list recommends cotton yarn for lamps.
A Plymouth-bound settler had to think several steps ahead: How will we get light after dark? How will we close the windows? What happens when winter arrives? Those questions had to be answered before the ship left Europe.
The Clothing: More Valuable Than It Looks
Winslow also recommended bringing enough clothing for the voyage and additional clothing for use after arrival. Clothing represented significant material and labor. The Mayflower Society’s research into Pilgrim dress documents garments made primarily from wool and linen, with inventories showing clothing in colors including red, blue, green and violet.
There was no clothing store in Plymouth. Garments had to last. They could be repaired. Fabric could be reused. Clothing could pass from one person to another. The coat hanging beside the door wasn’t just clothing. It was stored labor and value.
What If Something Broke?
This may be the question that best separates their material world from ours. Today, replacement is built into our economy. Break a plate? Buy another. Ruin a shirt? Replace it. Lose a pan? Order one.
For early Plymouth, replacement could involve repair, local craftsmanship, trade—or waiting for another ship. And ships were not reliable delivery services. The Fortune arrived in November 1621 carrying about 35 new settlers, but Bradford complained that they arrived desperately under-supplied. They lacked adequate clothing, bedding, food and cooking equipment. The existing colony had to help supply them.
An object therefore had a value beyond its purchase price. Its value included how difficult it would be to replace.
History Through Things
A cradle. A cooking pot. A musket. A sword. A Bible. A chair. A tool. A piece of cloth. None sounds as historically important as the Mayflower Compact. But ordinary objects tell us things documents sometimes cannot.
They show us what people feared they might need. What they valued enough to carry. What they used every day. What they repaired instead of replacing. What allowed them to cook dinner, build a wall, hunt for food, warm a baby or read Scripture by firelight.
The Mayflower did not simply carry 102 passengers. It carried pieces of the lives those passengers hoped to build. And perhaps that gives us a surprisingly good question to ask ourselves:
If you could carry only the things necessary to build your life again from the ground up, what would make it onto the ship?
The strongest visual reference is Pilgrim Hall Museum — It Came on the Mayflower, which documents objects traditionally associated with the Mayflower passengers. For what settlers actually needed, Pilgrim Hall Museum — Early Provisions Lists is especially useful because it reproduces contemporary advice and later New England packing lists.
For clothing, use General Society of Mayflower Descendants — Dress Like a Pilgrim. For the historical context of the White family’s cradle and Peregrine’s birth, use Mayflower Society — The William White Family.
Recent Comments