Let’s clear up one misconception immediately. The Pilgrims were allowed to have fun.
They did not spend every waking hour working, praying, reading the Bible or staring solemnly across Plymouth Harbor. They played games. They feasted. They visited. They celebrated weddings. They told riddles. They participated in physical contests. They watched demonstrations of skill.
And on at least one memorable occasion, Governor William Bradford came home from work to discover a group of colonists playing games in the street. He was not amused. But probably not for the reason you think. The historical record gives us intriguing glimpses into recreation in early Plymouth—and shows that the Pilgrims’ attitude wasn’t simply “fun is sinful.” It was closer to: There’s a time for work, a time for worship and a time for recreation. Please don’t confuse them.
First, We Need to Separate “Fun” From “Idleness”
This distinction matters. The Pilgrim Separatists believed human time belonged to God. That affected how they thought about work, worship and recreation. Pilgrim Hall’s research into children’s reading, for example, explains that Pilgrim and Puritan parents did not approve of children simply wasting large amounts of time on purely recreational reading. Reading was expected to contribute to education, moral formation and knowledge of Scripture. But that didn’t mean recreation itself was forbidden. We know that because William Bradford actually recorded people doing it. And he gave us one of the funniest little episodes in Plymouth history.
The Great Christmas Day Showdown of 1621
On December 25, 1621, Bradford called the colonists out to work.
That sounds strange to modern Americans, but the Pilgrim Separatists did not observe Christmas as a religious holiday. They found no biblical command establishing December 25 as Christ’s birthday and rejected many traditional Christmas practices. Some of the newer colonists, however, disagreed. They told Bradford that working on Christmas violated their consciences. Bradford accepted that—at least temporarily. If this was genuinely a matter of conscience, he told them, they could stay home while everyone else worked.
So Bradford and the others went to work. Then they came home around noon. And there were the conscientious objectors: Playing games in the street.
Bradford recorded that some were “pitching the barr” while others were playing “stoole-ball.” Bradford confiscated their sporting equipment. His argument was wonderfully straightforward: if their consciences prevented them from working because Christmas was a religious observance, then they should observe it religiously at home. They did not get to claim a religious exemption from work and then turn it into recreational game day while everyone else labored.
Four centuries later, managers everywhere may feel an unexpected kinship with William Bradford.
So What Is Stool-Ball?
Stool-ball was a ball game with English roots. The General Society of Mayflower Descendants provides a reconstruction of how the game could have been played during the Pilgrims’ period. One player defended a stool while another attempted to hit it with a ball. The defender tried to knock the incoming ball away with a hand. Depending upon what happened, players could score or exchange positions.
Sound vaguely familiar? It should. Stool-ball belongs to the family of early English bat-and-ball games that developed in various forms over time. Most importantly for our purposes, we don’t have to speculate that people at Plymouth knew it. Bradford caught them playing it.
And What Was “Pitching the Bar”?
Pitching the bar was a test of strength. A heavy bar—typically wood or iron—was thrown for distance or skill. Think less Xbox. More seventeenth-century Highland Games. The activity makes sense in a culture in which physical strength was part of ordinary working life. These were people who felled trees, split timber, worked fields, carried supplies, hunted and built houses. Recreation could turn those same physical abilities into competition.
Bradford’s Christmas account therefore gives us an unusually vivid snapshot of English recreation transplanted directly into Plymouth. People didn’t leave their games behind when they crossed the Atlantic.
The Famous 1621 Feast Included Recreation Too
The gathering we now call the First Thanksgiving wasn’t simply a meal. Edward Winslow’s firsthand account says that after Plymouth’s first harvest, the colonists gathered to “rejoice together.” Ousamequin—the Wampanoag leader the English called Massasoit—arrived with approximately 90 men, and the gathering continued for three days. There was food, certainly. But Winslow specifically says there were “other Recreations.” He also records that the colonists “exercised our Armes.”
The surviving account doesn’t provide a complete entertainment schedule, so we shouldn’t invent one. But we know the event included more than eating. Plymouth Rock Foundation’s educational material also describes recreation associated with the harvest celebration as including activities such as bow-and-arrow contests, military drills, foot races and wrestling.
Imagine the atmosphere. Dozens of English colonists. Around 90 Wampanoag men. Children. Food. Hunting. Physical contests. Weapons demonstrations. Three days together.
That is considerably livelier than the solemn dinner table portrayed in many Thanksgiving paintings.
Apparently Bradford Knew How to Throw a Wedding Too
Two years later, Plymouth gives us another wonderful glimpse of celebration. William Bradford married Alice Carpenter Southworth in August 1623. A visitor to Plymouth, Emmanuel Altham, described the festivities in a letter. Ousamequin was invited. He arrived with his wife, other Native leaders and a large entourage. According to Altham’s account, the Wampanoag brought venison and turkey. And then there was entertainment.
Altham described watching the Wampanoag dance, noting with obvious fascination both the manner and sound of the performance. That tells us something important about social life in early Plymouth. A wedding wasn’t merely a private ceremony. It could become a significant community and diplomatic occasion involving hospitality, food, guests and entertainment. Bradford—the same governor who confiscated the Christmas sporting equipment—was perfectly capable of participating in celebration. Context mattered.
Children Had Fun Too
This may be the easiest thing to overlook because surviving records were written primarily by adults about matters adults considered important. But Plymouth contained a remarkable number of children. Pilgrim Hall identifies 13 young children among those present at the 1621 harvest celebration, in addition to older children and teenagers. They weren’t miniature adults who spent every waking minute working. The Mayflower Society’s educational material identifies several kinds of simple games associated with seventeenth-century childhood. And some required almost nothing.
That matters because manufactured toys weren’t easily replaced in early Plymouth. Children could play games requiring balls, stools or ordinary objects, and physical games needed little specialized equipment. Children also had something requiring no equipment whatsoever: Riddles. The Mayflower Society notes that riddles entertained adults as well as children during the seventeenth century.
That gives us a delightful picture of entertainment before screens, recorded music or even a large supply of children’s books. You needed other people. And imagination.
Reading Wasn’t Exactly Beach-Book Material
What about curling up with a good book? Possibly—but Pilgrim parents had opinions about what constituted a good book. Children certainly read. Pilgrim Hall documents that Plymouth children read the Bible, catechisms and, as they grew older, material written for adults. Children’s literature was only beginning to emerge as a distinct category. Young readers might encounter fables and myths, but Pilgrim and Puritan parents placed strong emphasis on the moral and educational value of what children read.
So yes, children could enjoy stories. But the concept of: “I am going to lie around all afternoon reading something with absolutely no redeeming educational value” might have been a harder sell.
Fun Often Came After Work
This may be the biggest difference between recreation then and recreation now. Entertainment wasn’t necessarily a separate industry. There was no movie theater. No television. No theme park. No Spotify. No professional sports league.
Instead, recreation grew naturally out of community life. A harvest becomes a feast. A wedding becomes a gathering. Physical skill becomes competition. Conversation produces riddles and stories. Hospitality produces celebration. And after the harvest is safely gathered, as Winslow put it, people can “rejoice together.” That phrase may tell us more about Pilgrim recreation than a list of games ever could.
The Pilgrims Weren’t Allergic to Joy
The popular image of Pilgrims as relentlessly grim people misses something. Their religious convictions placed limits around certain kinds of entertainment. They objected to practices they considered immoral, frivolous or inconsistent with Scripture. They took work seriously. They took worship seriously. But they also feasted. Played games. Celebrated weddings. Tested physical skills. Enjoyed riddles. Gathered with neighbors. And rejoiced when hard work produced something worth celebrating.
Perhaps the Christmas incident gives us the distinction best. Bradford wasn’t angry because people knew how to play stool-ball. He was angry because they had just told him their consciences prevented them from working. Then he caught them playing stool-ball. That is a very different objection.
So if you somehow found yourself transported to Plymouth and asked: “Do you people ever have any fun around here?” The answer appears to be: Certainly. Just finish your work first.
And whatever you do, don’t let Governor Bradford catch you using a religious holiday as an excuse to skip work and then start a ball game in the street.
He has precedent for confiscating the equipment.
The most entertaining primary-source evidence comes from Pilgrim Hall Museum — Christmas in Plymouth, where Bradford himself records the 1621 stool-ball and pitching-the-bar incident.
For the 1621 harvest celebration, use Pilgrim Hall Museum — Primary Sources for the First Thanksgiving. Winslow’s surviving account explicitly describes the colonists rejoicing together, engaging in “recreations,” and exercising their arms.
For Bradford’s 1623 wedding and the eyewitness account of Wampanoag dancing, use Pilgrim Hall Museum — Plymouth Colony Menu and Foodways. For children’s games and riddles, General Society of Mayflower Descendants — Thanksgiving Activities provides useful historically grounded activities.
Additional resources include:
Pilgrim Hall Museum — Books for Colonial Children
Mayflower Society — Thanksgiving Activities and Pilgrim-Era Games
Pilgrim Hall Museum — Primary Sources for the First Thanksgiving
Plymouth Rock Foundation — The Pilgrim Story and First Thanksgiving
Recent Comments