Need a new frying pan? A hammer? Shoes? Sugar? A pane of glass?
Today, the answer is easy. Drive to a store or tap a screen and have it delivered to your door. Try that in Plymouth in 1622. The settlers of early Plymouth lived in a world in which most necessities had to be made, raised, brought across the Atlantic, or obtained through trade. Pilgrim Hall Museum describes the first decades succinctly: colonists had to “make, raise, or trade for most of what they needed.”
But that doesn’t mean Plymouth was an isolated settlement whose inhabitants made everything themselves. Quite the opposite. As Plymouth developed, its residents participated in a remarkable network of commerce connecting Indigenous communities, England, other European countries, the Caribbean and eventually markets reaching around the world.
So where did the Pilgrims get their stuff? The answer changes dramatically depending upon whether we’re shopping in 1621—or 1681.
First Rule of Plymouth Shopping: Bring It With You
The earliest colonists couldn’t count on finding manufactured goods when they arrived. That made packing extraordinarily important. Edward Winslow advised prospective settlers to bring such practical necessities as surplus clothing and bedding, iron-bound casks, meal, butter and oil, a musket with powder and shot, cotton yarn for lamps—and even paper and linseed oil to make windows in place of glass.
Later New England provisions lists become even more specific. A 1630 list included a felling axe, broad axe, handsaw, augers, chisels, hammer, shovel, spade, hoes, grindstone and nails. Household equipment included an iron pot, kettle, skillets, frying pan, gridiron, wooden dishes and spoons. Imagine walking through a hardware store and realizing that almost everything around you represents something an early settler had to think about before getting on the ship.
Forget your toothbrush today and you can buy another. Forget a crucial tool when emigrating to Plymouth, and the replacement might be 3,000 miles away.
Your Iron Pot Might Be English
Some things Plymouth simply couldn’t manufacture locally during its earliest years.
Iron goods are an excellent example. Pilgrim Hall states that the iron tools needed to build houses, cultivate crops and cook food had to be imported from Europe. The museum preserves an iron cooking pot traditionally associated with Myles Standish. It was made in seventeenth-century England and represents exactly the sort of everyday implement appearing on early provisions lists. Its original long feet allowed it to stand directly over the fire.
This helps explain why ordinary household objects could be valuable. A pot wasn’t just a pot. It represented European iron, manufacturing, transportation across the Atlantic—and an essential tool for feeding a household. If it broke, there wasn’t a housewares aisle down the road.
What Happened When People Arrived Without Enough?
We actually know. In November 1621, the Fortune arrived carrying about 35 additional colonists. Good news? Not entirely. The new arrivals were spectacularly underprepared. Bradford complained that they arrived without adequate food, bedding, cooking equipment or clothing. There wasn’t even a biscuit for them to eat. Plymouth’s existing settlers had to supply the newcomers from resources already strained by the previous winter.
The episode demonstrates why later provisions lists became so detailed. Plymouth couldn’t simply absorb dozens of consumers who arrived without the means to support themselves. In an environment of scarcity, poor packing became everybody’s problem.
But Plymouth Wasn’t Really Self-Sufficient
This is where the popular image of Pilgrim life becomes misleading. We sometimes picture the settlers gradually learning to make everything themselves. They didn’t. They learned to produce more locally, certainly. Farms developed. Livestock increased. Specialized skills emerged. But trade remained essential.
The colonists’ primary overseas trading relationship was with England. Plymouth also developed commercial relationships closer to home. In 1627, Dutch colonists from New Amsterdam visited Plymouth to establish trade relations. After the large Puritan migration established Massachusetts Bay and Boston beginning in 1630, Plymouth residents traded cattle and finished goods with the newcomers.
Plymouth therefore wasn’t a self-contained economic island. It became one point in a growing network.
Sometimes Plymouth Was the Seller
Trade worked in both directions. Plymouth needed manufactured goods from abroad, but it also needed something valuable enough to exchange for them—and to pay its substantial debts. One answer was fur.
Pilgrim Hall records that Plymouth colonists traded corn for furs with Indigenous communities in Maine. Those furs could then be shipped to England and sold at auction to hatmakers. Beaver fur was particularly valuable for producing fashionable felt hats.
Think about that supply chain: Corn grown in New England. Traded for fur in Maine. Fur shipped across the Atlantic. Sold in England. Turned into fashionable European hats. That’s not the isolated Plymouth of popular imagination. That’s international commerce.
And in a wonderful twist, Pilgrim Hall possesses a seventeenth-century beaver hat traditionally associated with Mayflower passenger Constance Hopkins Snow.
Thursday Was Shopping Day
As Plymouth developed, commerce became more organized. Farmers produced surpluses of different things. One household might have dairy products available while another raised poultry. Not everyone needed—or was able—to produce everything personally.
A market system emerged. Pilgrim Hall documents that in 1638 the General Court formally established a market in Plymouth every Thursday, along with annual fairs at Plymouth and Duxbury. That represents a major change from 1620. You still couldn’t order a frying pan from your phone. But increasingly, you didn’t have to make every item yourself either.
Specialization was developing. So was shopping.
Your Pantry Was Becoming International Too
The same thing happened with food. Even as Plymouth’s farms became more productive, imported goods supplemented what colonists could grow locally. According to Pilgrim Hall, oil, citrus and wine came from Spain and Portugal; sugar came from the West Indies; and spices arrived through international trade networks.
Estate inventories confirm the growing variety. The 1651 inventory of Plymouth Colony resident John Hazell included cloves, nutmeg, turmeric, cinnamon, saffron, mace, pepper, ginger—and white sugar. Pilgrim Hall notes that sugar was still particularly rare and valuable.
Suddenly the Plymouth kitchen smells rather different. Cinnamon. Nutmeg. Cloves. Pepper. Ginger. These weren’t growing behind William Bradford’s house. They arrived through commercial networks stretching far beyond New England.
By the End of the Century, Things Got Fancy
Now fast-forward several decades. The material world of late-seventeenth-century Plymouth looked strikingly different from that of the first winter. Trade networks expanded. Local industries developed. Boston craftsmen and merchants supplied finished goods. Through England, New England consumers gained access to merchandise originating across the globe.
Pilgrim Hall describes late Plymouth colonists obtaining fashionable goods including Delftware, Chinese porcelain, chocolate from South America, coffee from Arabia and tea from India. Delftware began appearing among Plymouth families in the latter half of the seventeenth century. Pilgrim Hall’s collection includes imported tin-glazed ceramics owned by later generations of Pilgrim families, objects associated with growing prosperity and changing tastes.
Consider the contrast. In 1621, Plymouth needed settlers to remember to bring their own cooking pots. By the later seventeenth century, some Plymouth households possessed brightly decorated imported ceramics. That’s an extraordinary transformation within a few generations.
Plymouth Was Becoming a Consumer Society
And this tells us something larger about the colony. Plymouth wasn’t frozen in the year 1620. The first generation struggled to obtain basic manufactured necessities. Later generations inherited farms, businesses, trade connections and an increasingly sophisticated colonial economy. Pilgrim Hall notes that by the late seventeenth century Plymouth’s material culture had become noticeably more elaborate. Growing prosperity and Atlantic trade gave some families access to decorative goods, fine textiles, silver, furniture and fashionable ceramics.
That doesn’t mean everyone was wealthy. Colonial society contained significant economic differences. But it does mean the familiar image of every Pilgrim spending decades in a tiny house eating from a wooden bowl is misleading. Plymouth changed.
So Where Did the Pilgrims Get Their Stuff?
The answer is: Everywhere they could.
They brought necessities from England. They made what they could locally. They raised crops and livestock. They exchanged goods with their neighbors. They traded with Indigenous communities. They traded with the Dutch. They traded with other English colonies. They imported manufactured goods from Europe. And eventually, through expanding Atlantic commerce, Plymouth households encountered products whose origins stretched from the Caribbean to Asia.
There was no Amazon. There was no hardware superstore. But there was something surprisingly familiar: A supply chain.
And like ours, it connected the ordinary objects sitting inside someone’s home to people and places that homeowner might never see. The next time a package arrives at your door containing something made halfway around the world, remember the Plymouth household pouring imported sugar into a dish, seasoning food with nutmeg that couldn’t possibly have grown in Massachusetts, or serving something from a colorful European bowl.
The technology has changed. Our desire to get interesting stuff from somewhere else apparently hasn’t.
The strongest all-purpose source is Pilgrim Hall Museum — Early Provisions Lists. It documents both the earliest dependence on imported manufactured goods and the later arrival of oil, citrus, wine, sugar, spices, Delftware, porcelain, chocolate, coffee and tea.
For Plymouth’s commercial relationships and the fur trade, use Pilgrim Hall Museum — Financing the Colony. For the transformation in household possessions later in the century, Pilgrim Hall Museum — Affluence & Style in Early Plymouth is particularly good. And Pilgrim Hall Museum — It Came on the Mayflower gives readers actual surviving objects to connect with the provisions lists.
Recent Comments